Italy fines Meta €805M: default-on is not consent
Italy fined Meta €805 million because a Facebook Android gallery feature was on by default behind one bundled permission. Ask consent per feature in your app.
Italy fined Meta €805 million on November 14, and the cause was a default setting. The Italian data protection authority, the Garante, said the Facebook app for Android read photo galleries for a suggestion feature that was on by default. About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. If your app asks for one broad permission and then hangs five features on it, this decision is about you too.
What actually happened
The feature is called "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook." It has been available since 2023. While you scroll, it suggests photos and videos from your phone to post.
The Garante found two faults:
- Default on. The feature was preset as active.
- One permission, many purposes. Gallery access came through a single permission that covered the whole app. A generic "enable other features" notice came first. It did not tell users that they also authorized gallery suggestions.
The legal basis is Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, the national version of the EU ePrivacy rules. That matters. Meta argued that the Irish regulator had jurisdiction. The Garante rejected that, because ePrivacy has no one-stop-shop. The authority also said the rule applies whether or not the data leaves the phone.
The fine is about 0.47% of Meta's global revenue, or $887 million per Reuters. Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off by default, including for people who already said yes, and to ask again with a separate, specific request.
Meta will appeal. It told Reuters the fine is "disproportionate" and that users must grant permission on the device before the feature works.
One limit: the case did not cover AI training. Meta denies that use. The Garante kept the right to examine a newer 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud.
Why the Meta fine matters for your business
An OS permission is not consent for every feature. Meta's defense was that Android asked the user. The regulator said that is not enough. The operating system prompt opens the door. You must still say what each feature does behind it.
Ask at the moment of use. Request camera roll access when the customer taps "add a photo," not on first launch. State the purpose in one sentence. Make "no" a real option that keeps the rest of the app working.
New features start off. If you add a feature that reads something already permitted, it does not inherit the old yes. Ship it disabled. Show a switch.
Limit the scope. Android and iOS both offer a photo picker that returns only the files the user selects. Use it. You cannot leak or misuse a gallery you never read.
Local processing is still access. "The data stays on the device" did not save Meta in Italy. Do not treat on-device as a consent exemption in the EU.
Key takeaways
- Italy's Garante fined Meta €805 million on November 14 over a Facebook Android gallery feature
- The feature was on by default behind one permission that covered the whole app
- About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected
- Meta has 60 days to switch it off by default and ask separate consent; it will appeal
- For your app: one consent request per feature, off by default, picker over full access
Does your app ask for more than it needs? We review permission flows and rebuild them so each feature asks for its own consent. Send us the app, or see what we build.
Sources: Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Reuters via Investing.com.
- #privacy
- #consent
- #meta
- #mobile-apps
- #eprivacy
Tommy Rush — Founder, Rush Commerce
Operator turned builder. 15+ years running operations — now shipping the systems businesses run on. More
Get The Rush Report weekly — one email, zero fluff.
Keep reading
TSMC employee data breach traced to a cloud provider
TSMC confirmed an employee data breach in an SEC filing. The leaked data matches records at a cloud service provider. Inventory the HR data your vendors hold.
Read itSignDrop Windows zero-day: SYSTEM access, no patch, no CVE
The SignDrop Windows zero-day uses CLFS and Defender to give a standard user SYSTEM rights. No patch or CVE exists. Keep CLFS authentication on and cut admin rights.
Read it